When to Resurface vs. Replace a Tarmac Driveway

Tarmac is a popular choice for driveways across the UK due to its affordability, durability, and smooth finish. However, like all outdoor surfaces, it will eventually begin to show signs of wear. At some point, property owners must decide whether resurfacing is sufficient—or if a complete replacement is required. At New Romney Driveways, we help homeowners in New Romney, Kent make informed decisions about their tarmac surfaces based on the condition, age, and performance of the driveway.

Understanding the difference between resurfacing and replacement—and knowing when each is appropriate—can save you time, money, and future maintenance headaches.

What’s the Difference?

Before exploring the decision-making process, it’s important to understand what each service involves.

Tarmac Resurfacing

Resurfacing involves applying a new layer of tarmac over the existing surface. It’s a cost-effective way to restore the look and performance of the driveway without removing the original base structure.

Ideal for:

• Driveways with superficial surface damage
  
• Minor cracks, fading, or loss of texture
  
• Structurally sound sub-bases
  

Tarmac Replacement

Replacement involves removing the entire existing surface and possibly the base layer before laying a completely new structure. This is a more intensive process, typically chosen when the current driveway is beyond repair.

Ideal for:

• Driveways with deep cracks, potholes, or sinking
  
• Failing sub-bases or water drainage issues
  
• Driveways over 15–20 years old
  

When to Choose Resurfacing

Resurfacing is suitable in many cases and can dramatically extend the life of your driveway—if the underlying structure is still in good condition.

Signs resurfacing may be the right choice:

• Faded appearance or minor scuffing
  Discolouration and light wear that affects aesthetics more than function.
  
• Surface-level cracks
  Shallow, hairline cracks without underlying base movement.
  
• Even surface
  No evidence of sinking, rutting, or pooling water.
  
• Minor edge wear
  Damage limited to the perimeter that doesn’t compromise the core surface.
  

At New Romney Driveways, we assess all driveways in New Romney, Kent before recommending resurfacing, ensuring that it’s a suitable and long-lasting solution.

Benefits of resurfacing:

• Cost-effective compared to full replacement
  
• Faster installation time
  
• Improved kerb appeal
  
• Adds an extra layer of protection against future wear
  

When to Choose Replacement

In some cases, resurfacing would only serve as a temporary fix. If the damage runs deeper or if the structural integrity of the driveway is compromised, a full replacement is the better long-term investment.

Signs replacement is the better option:

• Large or deep potholes
  Holes that extend through the surface to the base layer.
  
• Substantial cracking (‘alligator’ or fatigue cracking)
  A network of cracks that indicates underlying structural issues.
  
• Sinking or poor drainage
  Uneven surfaces or pooling water signal a failing sub-base.
  
• Multiple past repairs
  A patchwork appearance with repeated fixes indicates the need for a complete overhaul.
  
• Driveway age
  If your tarmac driveway is over 15–20 years old, full replacement may be more cost-effective than continued repairs.
  

Benefits of full replacement:

• Completely fresh start with new base and surface
  
• Improved drainage and structural integrity
  
• Opportunity to redesign layout, widen the space, or improve edging
  
• Longer lifespan and reduced maintenance costs
  

How We Help at New Romney Driveways

Our team at New Romney Driveways offers comprehensive driveway assessments across New Romney, Kent. We never recommend unnecessary work. Instead, we take the time to inspect the current surface and foundation, identify issues, and advise on the most practical and cost-efficient solution—whether it’s resurfacing or replacement.

Our process includes:

• Free on-site consultation and visual inspection
  
• Core testing of sub-base condition where necessary
  
• Transparent advice and pricing
  
• Quality materials and expert workmanship on every project
  

We work with homeowners, landlords, and commercial property managers throughout the area to deliver tarmac driveways that are durable, attractive, and built to last.

Conclusion

Deciding whether to resurface or replace your tarmac driveway depends on several factors—including the age, condition, and structural integrity of the existing surface. Resurfacing is an excellent option for driveways that are still structurally sound, while replacement is necessary when underlying problems are present. At New Romney Driveways, we provide professional advice and high-quality services throughout New Romney, Kent to help you make the right choice for your property. Contact us today to schedule an assessment and take the next step towards a smarter, longer-lasting driveway.

Call us on: 01797 330 699
Click here to find out more about New Romney Driveways
Click here to complete our contact form and see how we can help with your driveways.